The cheapest and fastest trains from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ
- Cheapest price on Nov 21
- $61
- Average ticket price on Nov 21
- $61
- Fastest journey on Nov 21
- 8 h 11 m
- Average journey duration on Nov 21
- 8 h 11 m
- Trains on Nov 21
- 1
- Distance
- 457 km
The best way to find a cheap train ticket from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ is to book your journey as far in advance as possible and to avoid traveling at rush hour.
The average ticket from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ will cost around $61 if you buy it on the day, but the cheapest tickets can be found for only $61.
On Sat, Nov 21, we found 1 trains from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ, including 1 direct services.
On Sat, Nov 21 the direct trains cover the 457 km distance in an average of 8 h 11 m but if you time it right, some trains will get you there in just 8 h 11 m .
On Sat, Nov 21 the slowest trains will take 8 h 11 m and usually involve a change or two along the way, but you might be able to save a few pennies if you’re on a budget.

4:25 PM 8h11 Buffalo, NY 12:36 AM New Milford, NJ $61 1 One-way 0 transfers

4:25 PM 8h11 Buffalo, NY 12:36 AM New Milford, NJ $61 1 One-way 0 transfers
Journey information
Overview: Train from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ
Trains from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ run on average 13 times per day, taking around 8h 45m. Cheap train tickets for this journey start at $96 but you can travel from only $54 by bus.
There are 5 trains per day. The earliest train runs at 04:48, the last at 13:44. The fastest train covers the 283 miles (457 km) distance in 7h 59m.
Plan this route
Journey facts
- Distance283 miles (457 km)
- Average train duration8h 45m
- Cheapest ticket price$96
- Trains per day13
- Direct trains5
- Fastest train7h 59m
- First train4:48 AM
- Last train1:44 PM
- Cheapest MonthApr
- Cheapest DaySat
- High SeasonApr - Jun
- Low SeasonOct - Dec
Understand & plan this route
Book with confidence
- Why book with Omio?Compare options, payment & support
Frequently asked questions about your Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ trip
Use these quick route answers to check fares, travel time, departure options, and direct services before booking from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ.
Live departures
Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ train times
The table below shows live departures for Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ trains for today, Friday, November 20. You can also manually refresh the results below to see updated train journeys.
| Provider | Departs | Duration | Arrives | Transfers | Tickets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() | 7:22 AM Buffalo, NY | 9h18 | 4:40 PM New Milford, NJ | 2 transfers | |
![]() | 12:25 PM Buffalo, NY | 11h24 | 11:49 PM New Milford, NJ | 2 transfers | |
This is the last train of the day. | |||||
Find all the dates and times for this journey
Train companies: Amtrak from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ trainsAmtrak trains will get you between Buffalo, NY and New Milford, NJ from $54. With over 1000 travel companies on Omio, you can find the best train times and tickets for your trip.
Amtrak
Companies, tickets, and onboard amenities between Buffalo, NY and New Milford, NJ
Review the details behind your booking, from operators and ticket rules to luggage, onboard amenities, accessibility, and route-specific travel policies.
FAQs: Trains from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ
Find answers to the most common questions about traveling from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ by train. From journey times and ticket prices to direct connections, first and last departures, and even whether the route is scenic, our FAQs cover everything you need to plan your trip. Whether you’re looking for the fastest train, the cheapest option, or tips for making the most of your visit at New Milford, NJ, this guide helps you travel smarter and with confidence.

popular train stations
Popular train stations from Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ
Most Buffalo, NY to New Milford, NJ trains use the Exchange Street Station to station pair. Use this guide to compare Buffalo, NY and New Milford, NJ train stations on this route, check city-centre transport, alongside checking practicalities like train station facilities and services.
Which Buffalo, NY station do trains to New Milford, NJ leave from?
Getting to Exchange Street Station from Buffalo city centre
Exchange Street Station train station facilities and services
Exchange Street Station has practical services for this route, including Wifi, Lockers, Parking, Dining, Taxis, Accessibility, WC, Hotel, Lost and Found Office, Ticket Office, Bike Parking, Bike Rental, Information Desk, and Luggage Carts.
Food and drink
Food options include: Pearl Street Grill & Brewery, Liberty Hound
Wi-Fi and ATMs
Free.
Tickets and information
Ticket office support is available at Exchange Street Station. Information desks are located in the main hall.
Luggage and lost property
Luggage storage is available at Exchange Street Station. Lost and found is available at the station.
Parking, taxis and toilets
Available at Exchange Street Station: Parking, Taxis, WC.
Bike and car services
Available at Exchange Street Station: Bike Parking, Bike Rental.
Accessibility
Accessibility facilities are available at Exchange Street Station: Elevators, ramps, restrooms.
Shops, hotels and contact
Nearby hotels include Courtyard by Marriott Buffalo Downtown/Canalside, Buffalo Marriott at LECOM HARBORCENTER, The Westin Buffalo.
